11+ Rules for Eating in Italy

One of the biggest things to look forward to the most when traveling to Italy is easily the food and drinks! But, there are several rules to keep in mind when dining and drinking in Italy. Chris Atwood with See Italy has come up with "11 Rules For Eating In Italy", but our agents have thrown in an extra couple of rules ourselves 😉 *Look for See Italy’s original article that is linked at the bottom of this post*

1. Pasta portions are individual-sized
Here in the United States, we have Americanized Italian plates to a crazy amount. Most Italian restaurants that we know, offer enormous portion sizes of their pastas that are easily big enough to share. This is NOT the case in Italy. The pasta in Italy, considered there as “Primo” is individually sized and this is not because the cook is being stingy. Italians like to stagger their meals. They eat their appetizers first, then their pasta and THEN their main entrée. By keeping their pasta dish to a smaller size, Italians hold on to their appetites long enough to fully enjoy all courses without feeling too stuffed. Leaving room for plenty of Tiramisu for dessert!

2. The pizza toppings are totally different in Italy
When ordering a Pepperoni Pizza in Italy, you will get a pizza pie covered in peppers. Why? Because pepperoni in Italy means ‘bell peppers’. Pizza originated in Italy, but again, we have Americanized the Italian Pizza to a crazy amount. For example, BBQ chicken pizza, Hawaiian pizza & yes, even pepperoni pizza originated here in the United States. NOT Italy. The traditional pizzas found in Italy are the Margherita (mozzarella, tomato & basil), the Marinara (which is just crust & tomato sauce), the Quattro Formaggi (white pizza with four types of cheese), and the Capricciosa (artichokes, ham, mushrooms, and black olives). So keep this in mind when going to order your favorite pizza pie in Italy!

3. You do not need to order the whole menu
As noted above, Italians stagger the way they eat. Enjoy the antipasta before moving on to the first course (pasta/risotto/soup). The second course is either a meat or fish dish. This is why you will NEVER see a meat or fish entrée served on the same plate as your pasta. Italians consider these as two separate dishes that should be enjoyed separately, with the pasta being served before the main dish. Insider tip: Split your antipasta and then order either pasta or an entrée. If you are STILL hungry, you can always go back for more 😉

4. ONLY drink wine or water at a restaurant
We come from a land with AT LEAST five drinks choices being offered on almost any menu here in the States. At many sit-down restaurants, Italians will only sip on two drinks; wine and water. The wine in Italy will be served in chilled glass bottles and will usually cost about 2 euros per bottle. The waiter will usually ask you if you want “acqua naturale” which is flat mineral water or “acqua frizzante” which is fizzy mineral water also known as sparkling water. Do not ask for tap water, most restaurants will refuse to serve that to you. House wines can be ordered by the liter and are usually the same price as the water! Most will offer wine by the bottle also.

5. Oil & vinegar are the only salad dressings offered
We come from a land with AT LEAST five drinks choices being offered on almost any menu here in the States. At many sit-down restaurants, Italians will only sip on two drinks; wine and water. The wine in Italy will be served in chilled glass bottles and will usually cost about 2 euros per bottle. The waiter will usually ask you if you want “acqua naturale” which is flat mineral water or “acqua frizzante” which is fizzy mineral water also known as sparkling water. Do not ask for tap water, most restaurants will refuse to serve that to you. House wines can be ordered by the liter and are usually the same price as the water! Most will offer wine by the bottle also.

6. No bread before pasta!
With foods like pizza, pasta, and focaccia most think that Italians eat nothing BUT carbs. This is actually not the case. When ordering pasta, Italians would never consider eating their bread before their bucatini. The bread that is served at restaurants is used to scoop up the leftover pasta sauce onto your plate and ONLY when you are finished consuming the pasta


7. There are no such things as “doggy bags” to bring leftovers with you
Italians love fresh, homemade meals. They do not appreciate leftovers the way we do here in the States. You must be careful not to over-order while dining in Italy. The pasta that is left on your plate will be taken away and not returned to you. So, enjoy the food that is in front of you while you can but do not expect to take it home with you. 
​
8. Some dishes will not exist in all of Italy
Rome is world famous for Carbonara. Florence is known for its Fagioli and Venetians go crazy for their risotto. Wherever you travel in Italy, each region will provide you its own flavors. So the food you enjoy in Rome will not necessarily resemble what you enjoy in Sorrento. Insider tip: before heading to Italy, do some research as to the local specialties in each of the places that you will be staying.
​
9. Cheese does not always go on your dish
It is not customary to ask for grated cheese on top of your dish. Sprinkling grated cheese on pasta dishes and Italian entrees is yet again a very American thing to do. Unless your waiter offers you a spoonful of grated cheese, do not ask for it. It is not meant to be on that dish or it will be offered after it is served.
​
10. Enjoy a caffe or digestive after dinner
Only foreigners will order a cappuccino with or after dinner in Italy. Italians would much rather order a caffe or macchiato after savoring a full, slow meal. Cappuccinos are filled with milk and cream and is considered much too heavy after consuming a bunch of carbs. It is also very common to order a caffe corretto after dining, which is a shot of espresso spiked with liqueur. Insider tip: NEVER pass up on dessert while in Italy.

11. Ask for your bill, when YOU want it
Here in the States, we are so accustomed to the waiter bringing us our check when we are finished dining. This is not the case in Italy. The waiters in Italy want you to sit and enjoy your meal and do not want to hurry you out the door. Instead, they will wait for you to ask for the bill (which you can simply do so by flagging them down and requesting the “il conto” when you are ready to pay because they do not want to rush you out the door.


12. Peel your fruits and vegetables

Italians do not consume fruits and vegetables with the skin on them. They will always peel the skin off first. Many think that this is because Italians think the pesticides are unhealthy but most will say that this is because of tradition. If you start to bite into a fruit that still has the skin on it, you will most likely have the fruit ripped from your hand and the skin cut off for you by a local. Don’t get embarrassed this way 😉

13. Arrive late to any dinner party or dining event
It is considered rude in Italy to arrive early or on time to a dinner event. Italians will always try and arrive just a tad after the planned time as to not rush the host or chef. 

Click here to read more of See Italy's article, written by Chris Atwood

Share

By Amber Humphreys June 13, 2025
There's nothing like hearing about a destination from someone who's just returned with fresh memories and insider insights. Travel advisor Anna Maria recently visited Hawaii, staying at Outrigger properties on both Maui and the Big Island's Kona coast. From watching whales breach off Maui's shores to exploring the volcanic wonders of Kona, she experienced firsthand what makes Hawaii such a captivating destination—and why Outrigger's authentic Hawaiian hospitality creates the perfect home base for island exploration. Whether you're dreaming of your first Hawaiian getaway or planning a return visit to the islands, her insights will help you make the most of every moment in paradise. In this Q&A-style blog post, she shares everything from must-see attractions and hidden gems to practical packing tips and the cultural experiences that made her trip truly unforgettable. Get ready to start planning your own Hawaiian escape!
By Amber Humphreys June 9, 2025
Leisure travel advisor, Maria Kazanas , recently welcomed back a honeymoon couple from their dream stay at Baglioni Maldives. They provided us with glowing five-star reviews and shared stunning photos from their two-week tropical escape, which took them from a private Beach Villa with direct sand access to an Overwater Villa Bungalow with panoramic ocean views and direct lagoon access. As first-time visitors to the Maldives, our clients' enthusiastic feedback has us eager to share the highlights of their luxurious island honeymoon. Maria's thoughtful planning and attention to detail helped craft the perfect all-inclusive experience for her clients, complete with romantic touches like private honeymoon dinners and daily villa decorations. In this Q&A style blog, our honeymooners will give you a look inside their luxury Maldives experience at Baglioni Maldives. Whether you're planning your first honeymoon or dreaming of an anniversary getaway, this guide will help you determine if Baglioni's indulgent tropical paradise is the perfect fit for your romantic escape!
By Amber Humphreys May 19, 2025
My mom and I went on our first ever river cruise with AmaWaterways this past fall, and we had an amazing time. It was unlike any trip to Europe I had ever done, and now I can’t imagine travelling in Europe any other way. The convenience and ease of travel was unmatched compared to doing it on your own. We were a little hesitant and unsure of what the experience would be like, but it truly exceeded our expectations, and we have already booked our next Rhine river cruise in 2026! Even if you’re not cruising with Ama, river cruising is its own category of travel that most don’t fully understand until you experience it for yourself. Keep reading to learn all the details you might not have thought or heard of when river cruising for the first time.
By Amber Humphreys March 25, 2025
Dark Sky Week is held every year during the week of the new moon in April, and in 2025, it will be held from April 21-28. This week was created to see the true beauty of the night sky by turning off all unnecessary lights worldwide and raising awareness about light pollution. Dark Sky Week was created by highschooler Jennifer Barlow back in 2003, and is recognized by the International Dark-Sky Association, the American Astronomical Society, the Astronomical League, and Sky & Telescope. Barlow wanted to create this week of observance, because she thought it was important to preserve the way that our ancestors saw the night sky and to get rid of any unnecessary lighting that is preventing us from having the same experience.
By Amber Humphreys March 14, 2025
The critically acclaimed HBO Max series "The White Lotus" has captivated audiences not only with its sharp social satire and compelling characters but also with its stunning filming locations. Each season transports viewers to a different exotic paradise, showcasing some of the world's most luxurious resorts against breathtaking natural backdrops. If you've found yourself daydreaming about visiting these picturesque destinations, you're not alone. Let's explore the magnificent filming locations from all three seasons and how you can experience the White Lotus magic for yourself.
By Amber Humphreys March 4, 2025
In the world of travel, where you rest your head at night can be just as memorable as the destinations you explore during the day. At Brentwood Travel, we believe that extraordinary accommodations transform good vacations into unforgettable journeys. From sleeping under the dancing northern lights to sharing breakfast with giraffes, these seven remarkable places to sleep around the world promise experiences that transcend the ordinary hotel stay.
By Amber Humphreys February 27, 2025
For travelers seeking nature's most breathtaking displays, spring brings a variety of blooms from the cherry blossoms of Japan to the tulip fields of the Netherlands and the lavender valleys of Provence. Whether you prefer river cruising through Europe's waterways, the immersive experience of guided land tours, or the luxury of curated cultural journeys, there's a perfect flower-focused adventure waiting for you!
By Amber Humphreys January 31, 2025
We challenged our travelers to share the most incredible snapshots from their journeys booked through Brentwood Travel in 2024. At our annual holiday party, our staff was each given three votes to cast on their favorite photos. With one 1st place winner, and two tied for 2nd place, it was a great turnout, and we hope to do another competition in the future. Check out the final results and honorable mentions below!
Lufthansa 's premium economy vs business class from st. louis to frankfurt
By Amber Humphreys December 19, 2024
Lufthansa now offers nonstop flights on select days from St. Louis to Frankfurt. Check out the difference between their premium economy and business class fares!
A poster for our favorite travel photos from 2024
By Amber Humphreys December 9, 2024
Our travel advisors have been all over the world in 2024! Check out some of their favorite travel pictures from the year.
More Posts